Are you taking your relationship to the next level and have decided to buy an engagement ring? Congrats!
Now comes the hard part — where you stand at a glass counter trying to look like you know what you’re doing.
Most people don’t, and that’s fine. You probably have a budget in mind and maybe a few saved photos of rings you like. The jeweler, on the other hand, does this all day, every day. That’s how people end up spending more than they planned, or buying a ring that looks lovely under the shop lights but has a loose stone by the following summer.
A little homework helps a lot, and most of it is easier than it sounds.
Ask for the paper first
We know paperwork isn’t the exciting part, but stay with us for a minute.
Any diamond worth buying should come with a grading report, and it should be from an outside lab, not something the store printed itself. The whole point is to get an opinion from someone who isn’t trying to sell you the stone.
You will come across the names IGI and GIA frequently. For an IGI-certified ring, you’ll see the size of the stone and its grades with a report number on it. Most often, that same number is laser-etched on the thin edge of the diamond itself — too small for the naked eye to see; you’d need a jeweler’s loupe. Ask the jeweler to show you the number. When you get home, you can enter it on the lab’s website and verify that it aligns with what you’ve been told.
If, during the process of asking for the report, you get pushback or lame excuses and the jeweler keeps changing the subject, just walk away and go elsewhere.
Mined or made in a lab?
This question trips up a lot of couples.
A lab-grown diamond ring has an actual diamond in it, the same material you’d find in a mined gem. The only real difference is where it came from. One was formed deep underground over a crazy amount of time, and the other was grown in a lab in a matter of weeks. It isn’t a cheap copy like cubic zirconia.
You also can’t tell the two apart just by looking at them, and even experienced jewelers need special machines to check.
Price is where you’ll notice the gap. For the same size and quality, a lab-grown stone usually costs a good deal less. Some people worry what the ring will be worth if they ever sell it, and that’s fair to think about. Most diamonds sell back for much less than you paid, and lab-grown ones usually get even less.
But a lot of couples don’t plan on selling the ring anyway, so for them, it doesn’t really matter. Pick what feels right for the two of you.
The 4 C’s without the fancy talk
Cut. Color. Clarity. Carat. You’ll hear these words a hundred times.
Cut is the big one, and people often skip it. It decides how much the stone sparkles. A badly cut diamond can look flat, even if it’s huge.
Color is graded with letters. D is clear. As you move down the alphabet, it gets a little more yellow. Once it’s set in a ring, most of us can’t spot the gap between two nearby letters. If the gem is set in yellow gold, it’s even less noticeable.
Clarity is about tiny marks inside the stone. Most you’d never see without a magnifier. So paying a lot more for “almost perfect” may not change what you see on your hand.
Carat is weight. Not exactly size, but close.
Our advice? Don’t chase the biggest number. A smaller stone with a great cut often looks better than a big dull one.
Don’t ignore what holds the stone
Funny thing: People take weeks to pick out a diamond, then they spend about five minutes on the setting.
That’s the part that keeps your stone on your finger, though.
Look at the prongs. Those are the little metal claws. Are they even? Do they hug the stone tight? Four prongs show more diamonds. Six hold it a bit safer. A bezel, where a thin ring of metal goes all the way around, is the safest of all.
Finally, think about the metal. 14-karat gold is a bit more durable than 18-karat; platinum is dense and tough (but also twice as heavy), however it will slowly acquire an ugly, soft finish. Some people love that look. Some don’t.
What will it really cost?
The sales price is not always the final cost.
Ask about tax. Ask about making changes — engraving, the certificate, resizing at a later stage … everything. The stone and ring setting are often sold separately, which drives the total price up quickly.
Have your jeweler put the full number in writing before you agree to it.
Read the small print
We get it, nobody likes this part. Do it anyway.
How long do you have to return the ring? Do you get your money back or only store credit? And if you get it engraved, can you still return it? (Often you can’t.)
Resizing matters too. Fingers change. Hot days, cold days, years going by. Check if the first resize is free. Some designs, like rings with stones all the way around, can’t really be resized at all.
Buying online and having it shipped? Make sure the parcel is insured and someone has to sign for it. An engagement ring should not be sitting outside your door next to a pizza box.
Then there’s the warranty. Most only cover things that were made incorrectly — not losing a stone or the entire ring, not dropping it down the sink. Some shops offer free cleanings and prong checks every few months. That’s really handy because loose prongs are a common way stones go missing.
Will the ring survive daily life?
Diamonds are very hard. But hard doesn’t mean they can’t break.
A bad knock at the wrong angle can chip one. Pointy shapes like pear or marquise are more at risk. So think about who’s wearing the ring: Do they go to the gym? Cook a lot? Work with their hands? If so, a lower setting will cope much better than a tall one that catches on everything.
One final thing
Take your time. Ask all the questions, even the ones that feel silly. A good jeweler won’t mind.
This ring is supposed to last a lifetime. A few extra hours of checking is worth it.
For more information about Stocktonia’s advertising and sponsorship policies, click here.
