This article first appeared in EdSource.
For decades, advocates for English learners have said districts must help students who do not speak fluent English learn the language and communicate with parents in a language they can understand, pointing to a 1974 Supreme Court decision and the Civil Rights Law of 1964.
But the Trump administration rescinded federal guidance on this issue last year and has since doubled down on its stance. Last month, the U.S. Justice and Education departments said they won’t enforce previous administrations’ guidance on English learners, student discipline and race in college admissions.
The decision marks the latest example of the Trump administration interpreting laws differently than previous administrations and walking back long-standing civil rights guidance for students. The announcement has sparked concerns that schools may scale back services for students and parents with limited English.
It has also created confusion among educators, researchers and education attorneys, given that the guidance documents had already been rescinded.
“I was actually in a room full of education attorneys when I saw this notice and I had to go to them and be like, ‘Am I missing something or does this just do nothing?’ And that was the consensus. Everyone was like, ‘They’re just doing this for optics. There’s no other benefit,’ ” said Josie Eskow Skinner, education attorney and partner at Sligo Law Group. She formerly served as an attorney in the U.S. Department of Education’s Office of General Counsel.
Guidance documents rescinded:
- Dear Colleague Letter
- Fact sheet on ensuring English learners can participate
- Fact sheet on rights of limited English proficient parents
The October 2026 notice says the Education and Justice Departments “plan to revisit these guidance documents in light of the Supreme Court’s decision in Loper Bright Enters. v. Raimondo.” In that 2024 case, the justices said that courts must now decide whether a law was followed by determining “the single, best meaning” of the law.
In a written statement to EdSource, Department of Education spokesperson Sabin Sidney said the guidance documents “were contrary to the letter of the law and designed to impose overly burdensome federal requirements on states and schools.”
“After the Supreme Court’s ruling in Loper Bright, it is clear that administrative actions of agencies must uphold the original purpose of the law; a test both previous administrations failed,” Sidney said. “The Trump Administration is restoring the rule of law while ensuring core civil rights protections remain intact.”
The move is the latest in a series of actions taken by the Trump administration to cut back the Department of Education’s Office of Civil Rights, including laying off hundreds of workers from the Office of Civil Rights. At the same time, the department announced multiple investigations into schools and colleges for allowing transgender students to participate in sports and alleged antisemitism.
Though it changes nothing in practice, the announcement sends a clear message to schools, advocates say.
Conor P. Williams, a longtime English learner researcher and professor at the Children’s Equity Project at Arizona State University, said the education department’s repeated announcements are “a signal that they aren’t going to be enforcing or sending civil rights cases down at districts.”
Some researchers said they are concerned about how some schools may respond if they know they will not be investigated by the federal government for not offering translation or English language help for students.
“We do hear stories from people that schools are dismantling their programs and firing their teachers,” said Julie Sugarman, associate director for K-12 education research at the Migration Policy Institute. “It’s the fact that they’re not being supervised, they’re not being overseen. So it is absolutely concerning.”
California law requires schools to teach students English and provide language support within every class. The state also has its own guidance, such as the English Language Arts/English Language Development Framework and the English Learner Roadmap.
Sugarman urged schools to keep their programs and services for English learners and parents in place.
“The Civil Rights Act and the Equal Educational Opportunities Act are still the law of the land,” Sugarman said.
Williams, the Arizona State researcher, said schools should also follow court decisions.
“Courts have consistently found that kids cannot be unduly separated from academic content on the basis of the languages that they speak,” said Williams. He said that could mean bilingual instruction, or it could mean making sure that students are not pulled out of class for English language instruction and always missing algebra, for example.
Parents, too, have the right under federal law to understand school communication, he said.
“You can rescind all of the past administration’s guidance on that. That doesn’t mean that the law just sort of erases itself or that the case law vanishes, too,” Williams said.
The lack of federal guidance could spur some states to codify civil rights education laws and increase enforcement to ensure districts provide the services English learners need, some advocates and researchers said.
The new Democrat-controlled Congress could also pass new laws to clarify that schools must offer English learners and parents interpretation services and English language instruction, said Leslie Villegas, an independent policy researcher and writer who formerly worked for the nonprofit policy institute New America.
“I think that there is an argument to be made for Congress to step up and enshrine some of these things that we have taken for granted because they were done through a court case or through regulations,” Villegas said.
Related ReadingCalifornia leaders warn schools: English learner rights remain despite Trump rollback
September 8, 2025Students with discrimination complaints left in limbo, months after California civil rights office closed
July 16, 2025Q&A: How the 50-year-old case that transformed English learner education began
March 15, 2024

EdSource is California’s largest independent newsroom focused on education.
